Oven-Poached Riesling Trout with Leeks in Low-Fat Cream Sauce

Delicate, tender trout poached in dry Riesling with fragrant herbs and a silky sauce—this elegant yet easy recipe for Riesling Poached Trout with Leeks in a creamy sauce with fresh vegetables brings restaurant-quality flavor straight to your kitchen. Perfect for a special dinner or a simple gourmet treat

Why You'll Love This Recipe For Reisling Poached Trout:

1. Foolproof Cooking Method: Oven-poaching is nearly impossible to mess up, ensuring perfectly cooked, moist fish every time - no more fear of dried-out fillets!
2. Restaurant-Quality Results: Poaching the trout in Riesling wine and the fresh herb cream sauce creates a sophisticated dish that tastes like it came from a fine-dining kitchen yet costs a fraction of restaurant prices.
3. Quick Yet Impressive: Despite its elegant presentation, this poached trout dish comes together in under 30 minutes, making it perfect for both special occasions and weeknight dinners.
4. Healthier Choice: Poaching is a light cooking method that preserves the trout's natural omega-3s while adding flavor through herbs and wine rather than excess fats.

Jump to:

• Rethinking Riesling: A Wine Lover’s Revelation
• Trout - Wild or Farmed
• Main Ingredients & Substitutions
• How to Bone a Trout (Head-On & Head-Off Methods)
• Guided Instructions
• Chef's Secret: The Light Cream Sauce Trick
• Finishing the Fish and Making the Sauce
• Frequently Asked Questions
• What sides pair well with this Reisling Poached Trout?
• Wine Pairing Suggestions for Riesling Poached Trout with Cream Sauce?
• Easy Oven-Poached Trout in Riesling Wine Cream Sauce

Rethinking Riesling: A Wine Lover’s Revelation

Whenever my husband and I would travel and pour Riesling at a tasting, we were met with the same reaction—people shaking their heads, crossing their fingers in an X, and backing away before they even reached the table.

"No thanks, I’ll pass on the Riesling."

I always ask, "Why?"—though I already know the answer.

"I don’t like sweet wine."

But here’s the thing—not all Riesling is sweet.

"Just give it a try." After all, isn't that the whole point of wine tasting? To explore new flavors?

And then it happens—the lightbulb moment.

"Wow, this isn’t sweet at all!"

Yes, late-harvest Rieslings are sugary, but a well-made Riesling balances bright acidity with floral notes and that signature hint of petrol. These wines age beautifully—some for 15 to 30 years—gaining complexity over time.

So how do you find a great Riesling? Price can be a clue, but more importantly, look at the region. Alsace Rieslings are often a solid bet, while Australian and South African varieties lean toward citrus and lime. California also produces some excellent dry Rieslings—just ask for one in the Alsace style, with crisp acidity and minimal residual sugar.

And next time you see Riesling at a tasting, don’t dismiss it—give it a sip. You might just be surprised.

Trout - Wild or Farmed

Fresh-caught and farmed trout each have their own characteristics, benefits, and drawbacks.

Fresh-Caught Trout

• Flavor & Texture – Wild trout tend to have a firmer texture and a cleaner, more complex flavor due to their natural diet of insects, small fish, and crustaceans.
• Varieties – Includes rainbow, brook, brown, and lake trout, depending on the region.
• Nutritional Benefits – Often leaner, with a higher ratio of omega-3s due to their wild diet.
• Availability & Sustainability – Can be seasonal and may have stricter regulations for fishing to protect populations.

Farmed Trout

• Flavor & Texture – Milder and slightly fattier than wild trout due to a controlled diet, making it more consistent in taste and texture.
• Common Varieties – Primarily rainbow trout, as it's the most commonly farmed species.
• Nutritional Benefits – Higher in fat, which can mean more omega-3s, but also depends on the feed used.
• Availability & Sustainability – More widely available year-round and can be a sustainable choice if sourced from responsible farms.

If you are lucky enough to be able to go fish for your fresh fish, all the better. Here's a little primer on learning How to Fish. 

Main Ingredients & Substitutions

• Trout fillets - Substitute with salmon, Arctic char, or cod for a similar delicate texture.
• Leek - Substitute with shallots or a mild onion if leeks are unavailable.
• Carrot - Use parsnips or fennel for a slight twist in sweetness and texture.
• Fresh thyme → Use dried thyme (half the amount) or oregano for a similar earthiness.
• Dry Riesling wine - Substitute with dry white wine like Sauvignon Blanc or dry white vermouth.
• 2% milk, cream, or half-and-half - Use coconut milk or a non-dairy creamer for a lactose-free version.
• Tarragon - Replace with basil or fennel fronds for a subtle licorice-like note.

How to Bone a Trout (Head-On & Head-Off Methods)

Whether your trout has its head on or off, the boning technique follows similar steps, but the starting point differs. Here’s how to do both:

---

Method 1: Boning a Whole Trout (Head-On)

This technique is ideal when serving a whole trout for a more dramatic presentation.

Steps:

1. Gut & Clean the Trout – If not already cleaned, make a slit along the belly and remove the innards. Rinse thoroughly.
2. Make a Backbone Incision – Lay the trout belly-side down and use a sharp knife to cut along both sides of the backbone, from head to tail.
3. Loosen the Backbone – Gently lift the backbone starting from the tail, using a knife or your fingers. It should pull away easily, bringing most of the ribs with it.
4. Remove the Rib Bones – If some remain, gently separate them from the flesh using the tip of a knife or tweezers.
5. Check for Pin Bones – Run your fingers over the fillet to find any fine bones and remove them with tweezers.
6. Serve Whole or Fillet – You can now serve the trout whole (bone-free) or separate it into fillets.

---

Method 2: Boning a Trout with the Head Off

This method works well when working with pre-cut fillets or a gutted, headless trout.

Steps:

1. Lay the Trout Flat – Place the fish skin-side down on a cutting board.
2. Make a Lengthwise Cut – Using a sharp knife, slice along the spine from the neck end to the tail, being careful not to cut through the skin.
3. Lift & Remove the Backbone – Starting at the tail, gently lift the backbone away, pulling it up and away from the flesh. Most of the rib bones should come with it.
4. Check for Remaining Bones – Feel along the flesh for any pin bones and remove them with tweezers.
5. Trim & Serve – Your boned trout is now ready for cooking or serving as fillets.

Guided Instructions

Chef's Secret: The Light Cream Sauce Trick

Here's how to create a luxuriously creamy sauce without the guilt: combine 2% milk with cornstarch! This simple technique delivers all the rich, silky texture you expect from a cream sauce while keeping calories and fat in check. The cornstarch works its magic to create that wonderful mouthfeel, while the 2% milk provides just enough richness without overdoing it.

Why It Works:

• Creates the luxurious texture of heavy cream
• Cuts calories and fat significantly
• Maintains the silky mouthfeel you crave
• Perfect for those watching their dietary intake
• Doesn't compromise on taste or satisfaction

It's a win-win solution that proves you don't have to choose between indulgence and health!

Finishing the Fish and Making the Sauce

1. When the trout fillets are almost cooked through (they should be mostly opaque but still slightly translucent in the very center), carefully remove them from the cooking vessel and arrange them on a serving platter.
2. Place a strainer over a medium saucepan. Pour all the cooking liquid through the strainer, capturing the liquid in the saucepan. Remove the strained vegetables from the strainer and arrange them back over the fish fillets.
3. Turn off the oven but immediately place the platter with the fish and vegetables into the still-warm oven. This will keep everything warm while you make the sauce without overcooking the fish.
4. To make the cream sauce:
   • In a small bowl, whisk the cornstarch into the 2% milk until completely smooth with no lumps
   • Bring the strained cooking liquid to a gentle simmer in the saucepan
   • Slowly pour the milk-cornstarch mixture into the simmering liquid, whisking constantly
   • Continue to cook, stirring frequently, until the sauce thickens to your desired consistency (usually 2-3 minutes)
5. Remove the platter from the oven and pour the hot cream sauce evenly over the fish and vegetables. Serve immediately.

Frequently Asked Questions

What sides pair well with this Reisling Poached Trout?

Light sides like roasted asparagus, steamed green beans, or a simple lemony rice complement the delicate flavors.

Wine Pairing Suggestions for Riesling Poached Trout with Cream Sauce?

Since this dish is already cooked with Riesling, a well-paired wine should complement its delicate flavors without overpowering them. Here are some great options:

Best Choices:

• Dry Riesling – Enhances the dish’s flavors while keeping a crisp, clean balance. Look for Alsace Riesling or a dry German Trocken Riesling.
• Sauvignon Blanc – Bright acidity and citrus notes make it a great match, especially from Loire Valley (Sancerre)or New Zealand.
• Chablis (Unoaked Chardonnay) – A lean, mineral-driven French Chardonnay that won’t overpower the fish.
• Grüner Veltliner – A great alternative with fresh acidity, a touch of spice, and citrus notes.

If You Prefer Red Wine:

• Pinot Noir – Light-bodied with bright red fruit and soft tannins; a great option if slightly chilled.
• Gamay (Beaujolais-Villages) – Fresh, fruity, and low in tannins, making it a delicate match for trout.

Want some more easy company-worthy fish dishes? Try one of these...

This recipe is highly modified from a 2001 Epicurious.com recipe but since that was my inspiration, I'll give them their due.